In theory, a game developer assigns Gamerscore to an achievement based on the difficulty of unlocking it. In an ideal world, you'd get 100G for reaching a major game milestone or doing something impressive, and earn 5G for something relatively simple. However, there are no strict rules for this implementation, so it's not always an accurate depiction of difficulty.
Even if a developer sets out to score achievements according to difficulty, they can only assign these values once. Gamerscore is a static value. Yet as games are patched, guides are written, and strategies are discussed, the relative difficulty of an achievement can vary over time. Xbox runs leaderboards between friends based on how much Gamerscore they have unlocked, but with this much randomness and variability in earning Gamerscore, how can it accurately represent how hard a player has worked for an achievement?
That's where we come in. Essentially, TrueAchievements reconfigures Gamerscore into a value called TA Score (TrueAchievements Score), which compares how many people have an achievement to how many people have played a game. This ratio is multiplied by the original Gamerscore value of the achievement to get the TA Score.
Over time this score will change based on the player count and how many of those players manage to unlock the achievement. We add up all of your TA Scores for each achievement you unlock, and that gives you your total TrueAchievements Score — which we also display all over the place on the site if you are registered and logged in.
You can find more detailed info on how and why TrueAchievements was created, and how it works to more accurately measure player success in unlocking achievements, in our article
explaining TrueAchievement score.
We recognise that even our more accurate approximation of rarity still doesn't definitively declare an achievement's rarity — some achievements are rare because they are broken, for instance. However, on the whole, we feel our TA Score is a pretty accurate way to measure your Xbox achievement hunting career — which is how we've become the biggest Xbox community site on the planet, with our members
competing in leaderboards, setting up
personal gamerscore goals, and taking part in
site-wide achievement contests.